Clint Eastwood might be known for his time in front of the camera thanks to the many Westerns he’s starred in over the years, but his time behind the camera as a director is just as significant. He’s helmed some of the greatest movies of all time, and won Academy Awards for such hits as The Unforgiven and Million Dollar Baby. That being said, in 2014 he directed what is perhaps one of the most controversial war movies ever, and while it may have been nominated for Best Picture, people still debate the validity of American Sniper to this day.
Starring Bradley Cooper as Navy SEAL sniper Chris Kyle, American Sniper is based on the memoir of the war veteran that was published in 2012, a year before his tragic murder. The movie traces his rise to becoming one of the deadliest marksmen in U.S. history, and the toll it took on him both personally and professionally. Also starring Sienna Miller as Kyle’s wife, Taya, American Sniper premiered in theaters on Christmas Day in 2014, and went on to gross more than $545 million at the box office. In addition to being nominated for Best Picture, Cooper also earned a Best Actor nod for his performance, though Eastwood was shut out of a Best Director nomination that year.
Related
10 Years Later, ‘American Sniper’s Fake Baby Is Even Worse Than You Remember
Despite becoming a critical and commercial success, the Oscar-winning war drama ‘American Sniper’ features an infamous snafu.
Hitting HBO Max on July 19, you can see for yourself later this month why American Sniper was so controversial, as it sparked discourse between the right and the left when it was released over a decade ago. Liberals took issue with the way it seemingly glorified the horrors of war, while conservatives lauded the production for the way it depicts American soldiers and the sacrifices they have to make to defend their country. Many others took issue with the accuracy of the film, saying that it misrepresented the truth in comparison to Kyle’s own accounts, exaggerating certain moments to portray the sniper as someone he wasn’t in favor of Hollywood hype.
‘American Sniper’ Divided Fans and Critics
Warner Bros. Pictures
Regardless of how you feel about American Sniper in terms of its accuracy, there’s no denying that the film struck a divisive chord with critics and fans. Certified Fresh on Rotten Tomatoes with a 71%, critic Robert Kojder called it “one of the best films of 2014,” noting that it’s “a truly powerful look at a man that, whether you believe he is a legendary hero or not, was tasked with incredible hardships and rough decisions on the battlefield.” We can certainly agree with that. Zaki Hasan had a differing opinion in their review, writing:
“Even when we remove discussion of the real Chris Kyle…we still have to contend with American Sniper’s problematic approach to and depiction of recent real life events.”
As polarizing as American Sniper was with critics, viewers were equally divided on how they felt about it. Many had high praise for Cooper’s performance and the film’s “powerful story,” while others once more called into question the events depicted in the movie. One Rotten Tomatoes user chimed in to say “the reality we know and the reality this film is trying to make don’t match,” which is certainly a valid concern. Yet, with most biopics, that’s almost always the case, as Hollywood has always been about the bastardization of truth in favor of the almighty dollar. They don’t call it show business for nothing, right?
You can judge for yourself how accurate American Sniper is when it lands on its new streaming home of HBO Max on July 19, 2025.
Source: Max/Rotten Tomatoes
Release Date
December 25, 2014
Runtime
132minutes
Writers
Jason Hall
You can view the original article HERE.
