Alleged Gilgo Beach Serial Killer Didn’t Put Up Fight During Arrest

Alleged Gilgo Beach Serial Killer Didn’t Put Up Fight During Arrest

We now know more about what happened when cops arrested the suspected Gilgo Beach serial killer — we’re told the guy didn’t put up much of a fight.

Suffolk County Police Commissioner Rodney Harrison tells TMZ Rex Heuermann was taken into custody without issue .. and despite being suspected of committing heinous crimes, we’re told Heuermann remained stoic throughout the process of his arrest.

Here’s how it went down, per Harrison — he says Heuermann was approached by detectives on the streets of NYC Friday … who then told him he was under arrest. We’re told Heuermann asked what for, and they told him it was for his alleged involvement in the Gilgo Beach murders from over a decade ago.

Harrison says Heuermann’s response was interesting … all he apparently said to the arresting officers was “I didn’t do that” — but we’re told he did so in a very somber way. We’re told he didn’t shout or vehemently deny anything … he just calmly said it wasn’t him.

Harrison says they then threw on the bracelets, and that Heuermann didn’t resist whatsoever — he went peacefully and quietly with them. Commissioner Harrison tells us the detectives subsequently read him his Miranda Rights, and that he requested a lawyer.

Some believed his detainment was a bit more dramatic — especially with footage that’s been released showing police trailing him out and about — however, it was anything but.

As we reported … NY officials allege Heuermann is responsible for the 2010 deaths of Megan Waterman, Melissa Barthelmey and Amber Costello. Cops also suspect he may have murdered Marueen Brainard-Barnes — the 4th victim — but he hasn’t been charged for that murder yet.

He’s pled not guilty to all of the charges.

You can view the original article HERE.

Fletcher Cox Says Jason Kelce Would Root For Eagles Over Chiefs In SB LIX Matchup
Fletcher Cox Says Jason Kelce Would Root For Eagles Over Chiefs In SB LIX Matchup
AEW Star Saraya Splits From Ronnie Radke After 6 Years
AEW Star Saraya Splits From Ronnie Radke After 6 Years
Guess Who This Lil’ Beach Boy Turned Into!
Guess Who This Lil’ Beach Boy Turned Into!
The best star-studded Super Bowl commercials of all time, from Cindy Crawford sipping a Pepsi to Ben Affleck and the DunKings
The best star-studded Super Bowl commercials of all time, from Cindy Crawford sipping a Pepsi to Ben Affleck and the DunKings
Sundance Film Festival 2025 Preview: 20 Films We Can’t Wait to See | Festivals & Awards
Sundance Film Festival 2025 Preview: 20 Films We Can’t Wait to See | Festivals & Awards
Acclaimed Crime Comedy ‘Ludwig’ Is Coming to Britbox
Acclaimed Crime Comedy ‘Ludwig’ Is Coming to Britbox
The 10 Best Erotic Horror Movies, Including ‘Nosferatu’
The 10 Best Erotic Horror Movies, Including ‘Nosferatu’
The Metaphor Years: Writing Lessons from “The Twilight Zone” | Features
The Metaphor Years: Writing Lessons from “The Twilight Zone” | Features
Mantra Of The Cosmos cancel gig as Zak Starkey suffers leg condition
Mantra Of The Cosmos cancel gig as Zak Starkey suffers leg condition
Joey Bada$$ appears to diss J. Cole on new track ‘Sorry Not Sorry’
Joey Bada$$ appears to diss J. Cole on new track ‘Sorry Not Sorry’
Whitesnake and Thin Lizzy guitarist John Sykes has died, aged 65
Whitesnake and Thin Lizzy guitarist John Sykes has died, aged 65
Bruges bell tower pays tribute to David Lynch
Bruges bell tower pays tribute to David Lynch
Ravens’ Ricard: Lamar winning Super Bowl is ‘inevitable’
Ravens’ Ricard: Lamar winning Super Bowl is ‘inevitable’
Unveiling the Variety of Sporting Events from Football to Tennis and Beyond
Unveiling the Variety of Sporting Events from Football to Tennis and Beyond
Lamar angry with postseason performance: ‘Tired of this shit’
Lamar angry with postseason performance: ‘Tired of this shit’
Hurts confident he’ll play in NFC title game despite knee injury
Hurts confident he’ll play in NFC title game despite knee injury
‘Back in Action’ Director & Star Almost Died Making the Movie
‘Back in Action’ Director & Star Almost Died Making the Movie
The One Consistent Thing On Fire Country Is That Bode Will Always Be Portrayed As A Hero No Matter The Circumstance
The One Consistent Thing On Fire Country Is That Bode Will Always Be Portrayed As A Hero No Matter The Circumstance
Netflix's 'Back in Action' Ending, Explained
Netflix's 'Back in Action' Ending, Explained
Clayface Gets the Proper Mondo Treatment With a New ‘Batman: The Animated Series’ Figure
Clayface Gets the Proper Mondo Treatment With a New ‘Batman: The Animated Series’ Figure
Crime London Presents Fall/Winter 2025 Collection at Pitti Uomo 105th Edition
Crime London Presents Fall/Winter 2025 Collection at Pitti Uomo 105th Edition
Your Sparkling Guide To Valentine’s Day Jewelry Gifts!
Your Sparkling Guide To Valentine’s Day Jewelry Gifts!
Top Showroom Founders Share The Secrets To Their Success!
Top Showroom Founders Share The Secrets To Their Success!
Fashion Reacts To TikTok’s Ban, Heidi Montag’s Major Comeback!
Fashion Reacts To TikTok’s Ban, Heidi Montag’s Major Comeback!