How I Met Your Father Finale Stuns Fans, Brings Back HIMYM Star



It’s been eight years since How I Met Your Mother wrapped its run on CBS and the season finale of spinoff How I Met Your Father brought back an original star.


Hilary Duff’s Sophie Tompkins made her way into McLaren’s pub on Tuesday’s season-ender and found herself getting some relationship advice from Robin Scherbatsky.


Yes, Cobie Smulders reprised the role, and it has got to be one of the stealthiest casting decisions in recent memory.


Far too often, big returns leak to the media several months in advance, but thankfully, this was a shocker kept well under wraps.


Ahead of the big meeting, Sophie questioned her relationship with Jesse after he told her that he loved her after they spent the night together.


“I once had a guy say ‘I love you’ on our first date,” Robin shared.


“Dude sounds like a real piece of work,” Sophie chimed in. 


“You have no idea,” Robin tells her.


“But a good piece of work. Which brings me to my advice: Do not waste your time being scared, Sophie.”


“Fear can make you run away from things that could be good — great even, things that are supposed to be a part of your story.”


“So, really think about it: What did Jesse do wrong other than say everything you ever wanted a guy to say, just faster than you expected,” Robin concludes.


Sophie goes back to Jesse’s apartment, but is left reeling when she sees him kissing Jesse.


“If I’ve learned anything at all about love, it’s that timing is everything. Sometimes, timing’s a bitch,” Robin says when Sophie fills her in about that part.


However, the two women agree to meet again in 20 years, which should be fun.


Bringing anyone back from the original series was always going to be huge for fans, and with the news that How I Met Your Father has been renewed for a supersized second season, we should probably expect more stunt casting.


“[Series creators] Isaac [Aptaker] and Elizabeth [Berger]’s inspired vision for How I Met Your Father has proven to be true appointment viewing that fans cannot get enough of week to week,” Jordan Helman, Head of Scripted Content at Hulu Originals, said in a statement when Season 2 was revealed.


“The lives of these characters, as portrayed by the immensely talented cast led by Hilary Duff, are just starting to unfold and we’re thrilled to bring more of this group’s journey to our viewers with a supersized second season.”


The spinoff catapults us back to the year 2021, where Sophie and her close-knit group of friends are in the midst of figuring out who they are, what they want out of life, and how to fall in love in the age of dating apps and limitless options.


Chris Lowell, Francia Raisa, Tom Ainsley, Tien Tran, and Suraj Sharma star alongside Hilary Duff.


What are your thoughts on the big return?


Hit the comments below.

Edit Delete

Paul Dailly is the Associate Editor for TV Fanatic. Follow him on Twitter.

You can view the original article HERE.

Serena Williams’ One-Line Question on Fear Resonates with Thousands
Serena Williams’ One-Line Question on Fear Resonates with Thousands
Gracie Abrams Is the New Face of CHANEL COCO MADEMOISELLE CRUSH ABSOLU
Gracie Abrams Is the New Face of CHANEL COCO MADEMOISELLE CRUSH ABSOLU
Lainey Wilson Gives a Glimpse Into Her Everyday Essentials
Lainey Wilson Gives a Glimpse Into Her Everyday Essentials
Megan Thee Stallion Teases Hot Girl Summer Fragrance Collaboration With Ulta Beauty
Megan Thee Stallion Teases Hot Girl Summer Fragrance Collaboration With Ulta Beauty
DESPINA MIROU: THE IMPERSONATION QUEEN OF COMEDY
DESPINA MIROU: THE IMPERSONATION QUEEN OF COMEDY
Despina Mirou Ranks Among Top Global Contenders in Johnny Depp’s “The People’s Artist”
Despina Mirou Ranks Among Top Global Contenders in Johnny Depp’s “The People’s Artist”
Short Films in Focus: Trapped (with Sam Cutler-Kreutz)
Short Films in Focus: Trapped (with Sam Cutler-Kreutz)
Hulu’s “The Testaments” Returns to Gilead For Another Timely Tale About Privilege and Complicity 
Hulu’s “The Testaments” Returns to Gilead For Another Timely Tale About Privilege and Complicity 
Growth in CD sales outpaces vinyl in the US for the first half of 2026
Growth in CD sales outpaces vinyl in the US for the first half of 2026
Teddy Swims covers Van Halen’s ‘Jump’ at Electric Castle 2026
Teddy Swims covers Van Halen’s ‘Jump’ at Electric Castle 2026
Lauren Laverne reveals blood and bone marrow disorder diagnosis
Lauren Laverne reveals blood and bone marrow disorder diagnosis
Some might say we are locked in
Some might say we are locked in
LeBron stirs up 76ers fans with ‘trust the process’ comment
LeBron stirs up 76ers fans with ‘trust the process’ comment
Swinney shrugs off low expectations for Clemson: ‘You get what you earn’
Swinney shrugs off low expectations for Clemson: ‘You get what you earn’
FIFA’s credibility crisis overshadows riveting World Cup
FIFA’s credibility crisis overshadows riveting World Cup
Argentina rallies late to stun England and reach World Cup final again
Argentina rallies late to stun England and reach World Cup final again
Big Brother Spoilers: Veto Winner Revealed After Explosive Arguments Rock the House
Big Brother Spoilers: Veto Winner Revealed After Explosive Arguments Rock the House
Big Brother Spoilers: New Head of Household Makes Surprising Nominations
Big Brother Spoilers: New Head of Household Makes Surprising Nominations
Married at First Sight Finally Quit Pretending It’s About Love – And I’m Here for It
Married at First Sight Finally Quit Pretending It’s About Love – And I’m Here for It
Silo Season 3 Episode 3 Finally Sees the Real Juliette Shine (Even Just for a Moment)
Silo Season 3 Episode 3 Finally Sees the Real Juliette Shine (Even Just for a Moment)
How Rowe Plastic Surgery Is Giving Patients Beautiful Results
How Rowe Plastic Surgery Is Giving Patients Beautiful Results
Why Sag Harbor’s Sage and Madison Is Like No Other Store In The Hamptons
Why Sag Harbor’s Sage and Madison Is Like No Other Store In The Hamptons
10 Chic Beach Clubs To Know In Europe This Summer
10 Chic Beach Clubs To Know In Europe This Summer
GQ’s New Global Fashion Director, Kate Spade’s New CMO,
GQ’s New Global Fashion Director, Kate Spade’s New CMO,