‘Shelby Oaks’ Director & Film Critic Explains How He Will Handle Criticism Towards Horror Thriller

‘Shelby Oaks’ Director & Film Critic Explains How He Will Handle Criticism Towards Horror Thriller

Chris Stuckmann‘s terrifying horror debut Shelby Oaks promises to be one of 2025’s notable releases in the genre, and fans of modern horror are already lining up for it. His first feature film releases in theaters on October 24, courtesy of Neon and their support for the content creator turned filmmaker. Judging from the final trailer, Shelby Oaks will go heavy on the scares, the result of Stuckmann’s strong passion for horror. But as any film critic making the bold jump into filmmaking would know, he understands that his film will come under scrutiny. So far, the opinions are positive, but can he handle what’s coming?

The director recently spoke to The Direct at Fantastic Fest, where the film premiered and received strong reviews. The festival run has been good for Shelby Oaks, and though everything may change during the theatrical run, Stuckmann seems to be prepared:

“It’s fair game. If I made couches and sold couches online, people would be like, ‘Oh, this couch is great. This guy didn’t like this couch.’ It’s just part of the thing. You make something, you put it out there, people are going to have an opinion on it. So far, so good. As far as currently, it seems like the majority are enjoying the film, which is great.

“But also, I made this film because I want to inspire other hopeful filmmakers like me, who can see someone who’s a YouTuber from Ohio with very little to his name, who’s able to get this done with the help of so many amazing backers. And the goal is to spread the love and the inspiration right back to people who’ve inspired me for so long.”

Shelby Oaks was written and directed by Stuckmann, from a story he came up with alongside Samantha Elizabeth. The feature met a few bumps along the way during post-production, but eventually, Stuckmann was able to finish the passion project with the support of horror master Mike Flanagan, who became involved with the project as executive producer.

The Inspiration Behind ‘Shelby Oaks’: Real-Life Trauma and Horror Mockumentaries

Neon

Chris Stuckmann faces the challenge of standing on the other side of film criticism, but there’s reason to believe that his attempt at original horror will make an impression. It looks like a film made by someone who is fond of the genre, and knows how to touch a nerve with fans. Stuckmann also shared the inspiration behind the movie, citing horror mockumentaries as inspiration for the film’s found footage elements, but also a personal experience with his own sister. Ultimately, his objective was to achieve a genuinely scary movie:

“That was kind of the goal from the beginning, to tell a film that I felt was creepy or sort of unnerving. The types of horror movies that have always done that for me are films like Lake Mungo and Noroi: The Curse, both of which are mock docs. Both of them are very, very strange and creepy like that.

“And I think that there is something about eerie, creepy vibes that have always actually made me feel fear in horror. I’m not always scared by some things that are more common in horror, but specifically movies that feel like they’re getting under your skin. And for me, I just wanted it to feel like something that was personal to our hero, Mia, in the movie. The search for her sister.

“As a young kid, I didn’t see my sister for many, many years because of the way I was raised, and I was ostracized from her and didn’t know exactly where she even lived. And so that sort of personal element of taking that part of my life and trying to put it into a story that also had a genre element, hopefully it pays off in that way, of making it feel emotional and personal, because usually those are the types of stories that scare me, the ones that feel like there’s actually something personal about it.”

Release Date

October 2, 2025

Runtime

99 minutes

Director

chris stuckmann

Writers

Chris Stuckmann, Sam Liz

Producers

Trevor Macy, Aaron B. Koontz, Mike Flanagan, Cameron Burns, Sean E. DeMott, Melinda Nishioka, Ashleigh Snead

You can view the original article HERE.

Gwen Stefani and Blake Sheltons Rare Outing Alongside Her Ex Gavin Rossdale Will No Doubt Raise Eyebrows
Gwen Stefani and Blake Sheltons Rare Outing Alongside Her Ex Gavin Rossdale Will No Doubt Raise Eyebrows
General Hospitals Randall England Dead at 75
General Hospitals Randall England Dead at 75
Lily Tomlin Reveals Dolly Partons Surprising 9 to 5 Preparation
Lily Tomlin Reveals Dolly Partons Surprising 9 to 5 Preparation
Frankie Muniz Speaks Out After Car Crash at Daytona International Speedway
Frankie Muniz Speaks Out After Car Crash at Daytona International Speedway
Netflix's Long-Awaited Fantasy Adaptation Finally Unveils First Look After 7 Years
Netflix's Long-Awaited Fantasy Adaptation Finally Unveils First Look After 7 Years
Goodbye VisionQuest, Marvels Paladin Knows Where He Should Appear Next In The MCU
Goodbye VisionQuest, Marvels Paladin Knows Where He Should Appear Next In The MCU
Forget Ebenezer, Johnny Depps Near-Perfect 105-Minute Gothic Fantasy Officially Sets Netflix Release
Forget Ebenezer, Johnny Depps Near-Perfect 105-Minute Gothic Fantasy Officially Sets Netflix Release
8 Hulu Miniseries Masterpieces You Can Watch in One Sitting
8 Hulu Miniseries Masterpieces You Can Watch in One Sitting
U2: You have to up your game when people step into the room like Fontaines D.C.
U2: You have to up your game when people step into the room like Fontaines D.C.
You Can See Everything review: an odyssey of deception
You Can See Everything review: an odyssey of deception
Kings Of Leon launch O My Beloved and break out classic hits and rarities at intimate one-off London show
Kings Of Leon launch O My Beloved and break out classic hits and rarities at intimate one-off London show
Bloc Partys Kele Okereke on recent racist and homophobic comments: I dont think me being visible means that I need to be subject to abuse
Bloc Partys Kele Okereke on recent racist and homophobic comments: I dont think me being visible means that I need to be subject to abuse
New Saints brush aside Briton Ferry in Welsh Cup
New Saints brush aside Briton Ferry in Welsh Cup
AP Top 25 Poll Prediction: Can Anyone New Crack the Top 12?
AP Top 25 Poll Prediction: Can Anyone New Crack the Top 12?
NFL official Don Willard to referee two games in Week 10
NFL official Don Willard to referee two games in Week 10
Ty Dieffenbach fought through the pain to lead No. 4 UCLA to victory over Illinois
Ty Dieffenbach fought through the pain to lead No. 4 UCLA to victory over Illinois
Russell Brand Accuser Mia Latter Waives Anonymity, Alleges Rape
Russell Brand Accuser Mia Latter Waives Anonymity, Alleges Rape
Insomniac City: All About Jonathan Baileys Gay Romance Movie
Insomniac City: All About Jonathan Baileys Gay Romance Movie
The Weekend Read: Marriage In MobLand, Johnny Depps Return, Kenyan Land Theft, A Hunger Games Breakout, Project Hail Marys 80s Pop Vibes & Shooting Wild Horse Nine
The Weekend Read: Marriage In MobLand, Johnny Depps Return, Kenyan Land Theft, A Hunger Games Breakout, Project Hail Marys 80s Pop Vibes & Shooting Wild Horse Nine
The Rainmakers Austin Nichols Unpacks Tom & Bruisers Past, That Severed Head Shocker & More
The Rainmakers Austin Nichols Unpacks Tom & Bruisers Past, That Severed Head Shocker & More
These Viral Thermal Jeans Kept Me Warm in Iceland
These Viral Thermal Jeans Kept Me Warm in Iceland
Editors Pick: Halfdays x Guest in Residence Alpine Coveralls
Editors Pick: Halfdays x Guest in Residence Alpine Coveralls
Vivienne Tam Revisits Her Signature East-Meets-West Style With Two New Collections
Vivienne Tam Revisits Her Signature East-Meets-West Style With Two New Collections
Tods Parts Ways With Designer Matteo Tamburini
Tods Parts Ways With Designer Matteo Tamburini