The first significant San Francisco Giants rumor of the offseason has arrived, and it centers on the team’s biggest breakout star of its otherwise horrible 2026 season: Casey Schmitt.
ESPN’s MLB insider Jeff Passan dropped a massive offseason preview on Wednesday and, in discussing the trades that could come before an expected MLB lockout begins on Dec. 2, had a nugget about the possibility of the Giants trading Schmitt.
Advertisement
“There could be some lockout deadline-beating trades involving hitters in the meantime,” Passan wrote. “Kansas City and San Francisco, both desperate to upgrade their rotations, have floated infielders Maikel Garcia and Casey Schmitt for pitching help.”
The nugget seems at least half-prescient now, as a few hours after he reported that in the story, the Royals reportedly agreed to a six-player trade to send Garcia to the Mariners for three pitchers.
Schmitt, a natural third baseman, was the Giants’ second-round pick in the 2020 MLB Draft and made his big-league debut in 2023. He was a part-time player over his first three MLB seasons, as he struggled to make contact at times and had high strikeout numbers. Schmitt appeared to be out of the Giants’ plans entering last season when the team signed Luis Arraez to play second base, leaving all four infield positions accounted for and seemingly relegating Schmitt to being a permanent backup.
But he got a chance to start at first base to begin 2026, because Rafael Devers wasn’t fully healthy. He pounced on the opportunity, batting .301 in March and April and effectively forcing his way into the lineup on an everyday basis. He continued to hit all year as he bounced around defensively, playing in left field for the first time in his pro career before filling in for Matt Chapman at third base and showing he still had elite defensive skills at the position.
Advertisement
Schmitt’s season, though, came to an end in July, when he tore his meniscus while running the bases following a bloop single. He finished with a number of career-high marks: 21 homers (tied for second-most on the Giants this year), 105 hits, 17 doubles, 55 RBI and a .271 batting average.
Still, the Giants ended the season at 65-97, with the pitching staff getting decimated by injuries and leaving the team “desperate” for more arms, as Passan reported. The Giants reportedly explored the trade markets for their highly paid hitters – Devers, Chapman, shortstop Willy Adames – last season but ultimately didn’t move any of them and don’t appear likely to move any of them now, either.
Schmitt, who will turn 28 before the start of the next MLB season, was undoubtedly solid-to-great for the Giants last year. But they still have Chapman blocking Schmitt’s best position. Schmitt is also arbitration eligible for the first time this offseason, with MLB Trade Rumors projecting Schmitt to get $2.5 million. That wouldn’t be a prohibitive cost to other teams, and those teams surely would value how Schmitt still comes with three years of team control.
Giants president of baseball operations Buster Posey said the Giants “have to be realistic” about their goals coming off a 97-loss season. The team doesn’t seem likely to be in position to be a contender in 2027, so making moves to bolster the team’s chances in the future would make more sense. And the Giants already made a move like this at the trade deadline, shipping Heliot Ramos to the Yankees despite Ramos having years of team control remaining.
Advertisement
Schmitt could help the Giants be better next year. But Posey could also use his good season to get the best return the team can for him now.
This article originally published at SF Giants reportedly have ‘floated’ trading Casey Schmitt for pitching.














